Date: 2005-11-17 Congress: 109-1
Question: On the Motion
Description: S2020 — To reinstate for millionaires a top individual income tax rate of 39.6 percent, the pre-May 2003 rates of tax on capital gains and dividends, and to repeal the reduction and termination of the phase out of personal exemptions and overall limitation on itemized deductions, until the Federal budget deficit is eliminated.
Result: Motion Rejected Yeas 40 / Nays 59 / Present None / Not voting None
Write-ups: none
| Legislator | Party | State | Vote | ID |
| Akaka, Daniel Kahikina |
D | HI |
Yea | A000069 |
| Alexander, Lamar |
R | TN |
Nay | A000360 |
| Allard, A. Wayne |
R | CO |
Nay | A000109 |
| Allen, George |
R | VA |
Nay | A000121 |
| Baucus, Max Sieben |
D | MT |
Nay | B000243 |
| Bayh, Evan |
D | IN |
Yea | B001233 |
| Bennett, Robert Foster (Bob) |
R | UT |
Nay | B000382 |
| Biden, Joseph Robinette (Joe), Jr. |
D | DE |
Yea | B000444 |
| Bingaman, Jesse Francis (Jeff), Jr. |
D | NM |
Nay | B000468 |
| Bond, Christopher Samuel (Kit) |
R | MO |
Nay | B000611 |
| Boxer, Barbara |
D | CA |
Yea | B000711 |
| Brownback, Sam Dale |
R | KS |
Nay | B000953 |
| Bunning, James Paul David |
R | KY |
Nay | B001066 |
| Burns, Conrad |
R | MT |
Nay | B001126 |
| Burr, Richard M. |
R | NC |
Nay | B001135 |
| Byrd, Robert Carlyle |
D | WV |
Yea | B001210 |
| Cantwell, Maria E. |
D | WA |
Nay | C000127 |
| Carper, Thomas Richard |
D | DE |
Yea | C000174 |
| Chafee, Lincoln Davenport |
R | RI |
Yea | C001040 |
| Chambliss, Saxby |
R | GA |
Nay | C000286 |
| Clinton, Hillary Rodham |
D | NY |
Yea | C001041 |
| Coburn, Thomas Allen |
R | OK |
Nay | C000560 |
| Cochran, William Thad |
R | MS |
Nay | C000567 |
| Coleman, Norm |
R | MN |
Nay | C001057 |
| Collins, Susan Margaret |
R | ME |
Nay | C001035 |
| Conrad, Kent |
D | ND |
Yea | C000705 |
| Cornyn, John |
R | TX |
Nay | C001056 |
| Corzine, Jon Stevens |
D | NJ |
Not Voting | C001042 |
| Craig, Larry Edwin |
R | ID |
Nay | C000858 |
| Crapo, Michael Dean |
R | ID |
Nay | C000880 |
| Dayton, Mark |
D | MN |
Yea | D000596 |
| DeMint, James W. |
R | SC |
Nay | D000595 |
| Dewine, Michael |
R | OH |
Nay | D000294 |
| Dodd, Christopher John |
D | CT |
Yea | D000388 |
| Dole, Elizabeth Hanford |
R | NC |
Nay | D000601 |
| Domenici, Pete Vichi |
R | NM |
Nay | D000407 |
| Dorgan, Byron Leslie |
D | ND |
Yea | D000432 |
| Durbin, Richard Joseph |
D | IL |
Yea | D000563 |
| Ensign, John Eric |
R | NV |
Nay | E000194 |
| Enzi, Michael B. |
R | WY |
Nay | E000285 |
| Feingold, Russell Dana |
D | WI |
Yea | F000061 |
| Feinstein, Dianne |
D | CA |
Yea | F000062 |
| Frist, William H. |
R | TN |
Nay | F000439 |
| Graham, Lindsey O. |
R | SC |
Nay | G000359 |
| Grassley, Charles Ernest |
R | IA |
Nay | G000386 |
| Gregg, Judd Alan |
R | NH |
Nay | G000445 |
| Hagel, Charles Timothy (Chuck) |
R | NE |
Nay | H001028 |
| Harkin, Thomas Richard (Tom) |
D | IA |
Yea | H000206 |
| Hatch, Orrin Grant |
R | UT |
Nay | H000338 |
| Hutchison, Kathryn Ann Bailey (Kay) |
R | TX |
Nay | H001016 |
| Inhofe, James Mountain |
R | OK |
Nay | I000024 |
| Inouye, Daniel Ken |
D | HI |
Yea | I000025 |
| Isakson, Johnny |
R | GA |
Nay | I000055 |
| Jeffords, James Merrill |
I | VT |
Yea | J000072 |
| Johnson, Timothy Peter (Tim) |
D | SD |
Yea | J000177 |
| Kennedy, Edward Moore (Ted) |
D | MA |
Yea | K000105 |
| Kerry, John Forbes |
D | MA |
Yea | K000148 |
| Kohl, Herbert H. |
D | WI |
Yea | K000305 |
| Kyl, Jon Llewellyn |
R | AZ |
Nay | K000352 |
| Landrieu, Mary L. |
D | LA |
Nay | L000550 |
| Lautenberg, Frank Raleigh |
D | NJ |
Yea | L000123 |
| Leahy, Patrick Joseph |
D | VT |
Yea | L000174 |
| Levin, Carl |
D | MI |
Yea | L000261 |
| Lieberman, Joseph I. |
ID | CT |
Yea | L000304 |
| Lincoln, Blanche Lambert |
D | AR |
Yea | L000035 |
| Lott, Chester Trent |
R | MS |
Nay | L000447 |
| Lugar, Richard Green |
R | IN |
Nay | L000504 |
| Martinez, Melquiades R. (Mel) |
R | FL |
Nay | M001162 |
| McCain, John Sidney, III |
R | AZ |
Nay | M000303 |
| McConnell, Addison Mitchell (Mitch) |
R | KY |
Nay | M000355 |
| Mikulski, Barbara Ann |
D | MD |
Yea | M000702 |
| Murkowski, Lisa |
R | AK |
Nay | M001153 |
| Murray, Patty |
D | WA |
Yea | M001111 |
| Nelson, Clarence William (Bill) |
D | FL |
Yea | N000032 |
| Nelson, Earl Benjamin (Ben) |
D | NE |
Nay | N000180 |
| Obama, Barack |
D | IL |
Yea | O000167 |
| Pryor, Mark |
D | AR |
Yea | P000590 |
| Reed, John F. (Jack) |
D | RI |
Yea | R000122 |
| Reid, Harry |
D | NV |
Yea | R000146 |
| Roberts, Charles Patrick (Pat) |
R | KS |
Nay | R000307 |
| Rockefeller, John Davison (Jay), IV |
D | WV |
Yea | R000361 |
| Salazar, Kenneth Lee |
D | CO |
Yea | S001163 |
| Santorum, Richard John (Rick) |
R | PA |
Nay | S000059 |
| Sarbanes, Paul Spyros |
D | MD |
Yea | S000064 |
| Schumer, Charles Ellis (Chuck) |
D | NY |
Yea | S000148 |
| Sessions, Jefferson Beauregard (Jeff), III |
R | AL |
Nay | S001141 |
| Shelby, Richard C. |
R | AL |
Nay | S000320 |
| Smith, Gordon Harold |
R | OR |
Nay | S001142 |
| Snowe, Olympia Jean |
R | ME |
Nay | S000663 |
| Specter, Arlen |
D | PA |
Nay | S000709 |
| Stabenow, Deborah Ann |
D | MI |
Yea | S000770 |
| Stevens, Theodore Fulton (Ted) |
R | AK |
Nay | S000888 |
| Sununu, John E. |
R | NH |
Nay | S001078 |
| Talent, James Matthes |
R | MO |
Nay | T000024 |
| Thomas, Craig Lyle |
R | WY |
Nay | T000162 |
| Thune, John |
R | SD |
Nay | T000250 |
| Vitter, David |
R | LA |
Nay | V000127 |
| Voinovich, George Victor |
R | OH |
Nay | V000126 |
| Warner, John William |
R | VA |
Nay | W000154 |
| Wyden, Ronald Lee |
D | OR |
Yea | W000779 |